full transcript

From the Ted Talk by Dan Van der Vieren: Can you solve "Einstein's Riddle"?


Unscramble the Blue Letters


Before he turned physics upside down, a ynuog arlebt eeinitsn supposedly showed off his geunis by devising a celopmx riddle involving this list of clues. Can you resist tlkaicng a bairn teaser werttin by one of the smartest people in history? Let's give it a shot. The world's rarest fish has been stolen from the city aquarium. The police have followed the scent to a street with five identical looking huoess. But they can't search all the houses at once, and if they pick the wrong one, the thief will know they're on his trail. It's up to you, the city's best detective, to solve the case. When you arrive on the scene, the police tell you what they know. One: each house's onwer is of a different nationality, drinks a different beverage, and smokes a different type of cigar. Two: each house's itneiorr wllas are pantied a different cloor. Three: each house contains a different animal, one of which is the fish. After a few hours of expert sleuthing, you gather some cuels. It may look like a lot of iftmanoiron, but there's a celar logical path to the sotuilon. svoinlg the puzzle will be a lot like Sudoku, so you may find it helpful to organize your information in a grid, like this. psuae the video on the following screen to examine your clues and slove the riddle. aswner in: 3 2 1 To start, you fill in the information from clues eight and nine. Immediately, you also realize that since the Norwegian is at the end of the street, there's only one house next to him, which must be the one with the blue walls in clue fourteen. Clue five says the green-walled house's owner drinks coffee. It can't be the center house since you already know its owner drinks milk, but it also can't be the second house, which you know has blue walls. And since clue four says the green-walled house must be directly to the left of the white-walled one, it can't be the first or fifth house either. The only place left for the green-walled house with the cfofee drinker is the fotruh spot, mineang the white-walled house is the fifth. Clue one gives you a nationality and a color. Since the only column missing both these values is the center one, this must be the Brit's red-walled home. Now that the only unassigned wall color is yellow, this must be applied to the first house, where clue seven says the Dunhill smoker lives. And clue eleven tells you that the owner of the horse is next door, which can only be the second hosue. The next step is to figure out what the Norwegian in the first house drinks. It can't be tea, clue three tells you that's the Dane. As per clue twelve, it can't be root beer since that person smokes bltasuemer, and since you already assigned milk and coffee, it must be water. From clue fifteen, you know that the Norwegian's nbhoiegr, who can only be in the second house, smokes bdelns. Now that the only spot in the grid without a cagir and a drink is in the fifth column, that must be the home of the person in clue twelve. And since this leaves only the second house without a drink, the tea-drinking Dane must live there. The fourth house is now the only one missing a nttainaoily and a cigar brand, so the Prince-smoking German from clue thirteen must live there. Through elimination, you can conclude that the Brit semoks Pall Mall and the Swede lives in the fifth house, while clue six and clue two tell you that these two have a bird and a dog, respectively. Clue ten tells you that the cat owner lives next to the Blend-smoking Dane, putting him in the first house. Now with only one spot left on the grid, you know that the gmaern in the green-walled house must be the culprit. You and the police burst into the house, catinchg the tiehf fish-handed. While that explanation was straightforward, solving plezuzs like this often involves false starts and dead ends. Part of the trick is to use the process of elimination and lots of trial and error to hone in on the right pieces, and the more logic puzzles you solve, the better your intuition will be for when and where there's enough information to make your deductions. And did young Einstein really wtire this plzzue? Probably not. There's no evidence he did, and some of the brands moentnied are too recent. But the logic here is not so different from what you'd use to solve equations with multiple variables, even those describing the nature of the universe.

Open Cloze


Before he turned physics upside down, a _____ ______ ________ supposedly showed off his ______ by devising a _______ riddle involving this list of clues. Can you resist ________ a _____ teaser _______ by one of the smartest people in history? Let's give it a shot. The world's rarest fish has been stolen from the city aquarium. The police have followed the scent to a street with five identical looking ______. But they can't search all the houses at once, and if they pick the wrong one, the thief will know they're on his trail. It's up to you, the city's best detective, to solve the case. When you arrive on the scene, the police tell you what they know. One: each house's _____ is of a different nationality, drinks a different beverage, and smokes a different type of cigar. Two: each house's ________ _____ are _______ a different _____. Three: each house contains a different animal, one of which is the fish. After a few hours of expert sleuthing, you gather some _____. It may look like a lot of ___________, but there's a _____ logical path to the ________. _______ the puzzle will be a lot like Sudoku, so you may find it helpful to organize your information in a grid, like this. _____ the video on the following screen to examine your clues and _____ the riddle. ______ in: 3 2 1 To start, you fill in the information from clues eight and nine. Immediately, you also realize that since the Norwegian is at the end of the street, there's only one house next to him, which must be the one with the blue walls in clue fourteen. Clue five says the green-walled house's owner drinks coffee. It can't be the center house since you already know its owner drinks milk, but it also can't be the second house, which you know has blue walls. And since clue four says the green-walled house must be directly to the left of the white-walled one, it can't be the first or fifth house either. The only place left for the green-walled house with the ______ drinker is the ______ spot, _______ the white-walled house is the fifth. Clue one gives you a nationality and a color. Since the only column missing both these values is the center one, this must be the Brit's red-walled home. Now that the only unassigned wall color is yellow, this must be applied to the first house, where clue seven says the Dunhill smoker lives. And clue eleven tells you that the owner of the horse is next door, which can only be the second _____. The next step is to figure out what the Norwegian in the first house drinks. It can't be tea, clue three tells you that's the Dane. As per clue twelve, it can't be root beer since that person smokes __________, and since you already assigned milk and coffee, it must be water. From clue fifteen, you know that the Norwegian's ________, who can only be in the second house, smokes ______. Now that the only spot in the grid without a _____ and a drink is in the fifth column, that must be the home of the person in clue twelve. And since this leaves only the second house without a drink, the tea-drinking Dane must live there. The fourth house is now the only one missing a ___________ and a cigar brand, so the Prince-smoking German from clue thirteen must live there. Through elimination, you can conclude that the Brit ______ Pall Mall and the Swede lives in the fifth house, while clue six and clue two tell you that these two have a bird and a dog, respectively. Clue ten tells you that the cat owner lives next to the Blend-smoking Dane, putting him in the first house. Now with only one spot left on the grid, you know that the ______ in the green-walled house must be the culprit. You and the police burst into the house, ________ the _____ fish-handed. While that explanation was straightforward, solving _______ like this often involves false starts and dead ends. Part of the trick is to use the process of elimination and lots of trial and error to hone in on the right pieces, and the more logic puzzles you solve, the better your intuition will be for when and where there's enough information to make your deductions. And did young Einstein really _____ this ______? Probably not. There's no evidence he did, and some of the brands _________ are too recent. But the logic here is not so different from what you'd use to solve equations with multiple variables, even those describing the nature of the universe.

Solution


  1. painted
  2. owner
  3. puzzle
  4. interior
  5. pause
  6. young
  7. solve
  8. house
  9. albert
  10. answer
  11. solution
  12. color
  13. brain
  14. catching
  15. write
  16. fourth
  17. neighbor
  18. clear
  19. thief
  20. puzzles
  21. information
  22. tackling
  23. complex
  24. german
  25. nationality
  26. clues
  27. einstein
  28. written
  29. houses
  30. mentioned
  31. solving
  32. meaning
  33. blends
  34. cigar
  35. coffee
  36. walls
  37. bluemaster
  38. genius
  39. smokes

Original Text


Before he turned physics upside down, a young Albert Einstein supposedly showed off his genius by devising a complex riddle involving this list of clues. Can you resist tackling a brain teaser written by one of the smartest people in history? Let's give it a shot. The world's rarest fish has been stolen from the city aquarium. The police have followed the scent to a street with five identical looking houses. But they can't search all the houses at once, and if they pick the wrong one, the thief will know they're on his trail. It's up to you, the city's best detective, to solve the case. When you arrive on the scene, the police tell you what they know. One: each house's owner is of a different nationality, drinks a different beverage, and smokes a different type of cigar. Two: each house's interior walls are painted a different color. Three: each house contains a different animal, one of which is the fish. After a few hours of expert sleuthing, you gather some clues. It may look like a lot of information, but there's a clear logical path to the solution. Solving the puzzle will be a lot like Sudoku, so you may find it helpful to organize your information in a grid, like this. Pause the video on the following screen to examine your clues and solve the riddle. Answer in: 3 2 1 To start, you fill in the information from clues eight and nine. Immediately, you also realize that since the Norwegian is at the end of the street, there's only one house next to him, which must be the one with the blue walls in clue fourteen. Clue five says the green-walled house's owner drinks coffee. It can't be the center house since you already know its owner drinks milk, but it also can't be the second house, which you know has blue walls. And since clue four says the green-walled house must be directly to the left of the white-walled one, it can't be the first or fifth house either. The only place left for the green-walled house with the coffee drinker is the fourth spot, meaning the white-walled house is the fifth. Clue one gives you a nationality and a color. Since the only column missing both these values is the center one, this must be the Brit's red-walled home. Now that the only unassigned wall color is yellow, this must be applied to the first house, where clue seven says the Dunhill smoker lives. And clue eleven tells you that the owner of the horse is next door, which can only be the second house. The next step is to figure out what the Norwegian in the first house drinks. It can't be tea, clue three tells you that's the Dane. As per clue twelve, it can't be root beer since that person smokes Bluemaster, and since you already assigned milk and coffee, it must be water. From clue fifteen, you know that the Norwegian's neighbor, who can only be in the second house, smokes Blends. Now that the only spot in the grid without a cigar and a drink is in the fifth column, that must be the home of the person in clue twelve. And since this leaves only the second house without a drink, the tea-drinking Dane must live there. The fourth house is now the only one missing a nationality and a cigar brand, so the Prince-smoking German from clue thirteen must live there. Through elimination, you can conclude that the Brit smokes Pall Mall and the Swede lives in the fifth house, while clue six and clue two tell you that these two have a bird and a dog, respectively. Clue ten tells you that the cat owner lives next to the Blend-smoking Dane, putting him in the first house. Now with only one spot left on the grid, you know that the German in the green-walled house must be the culprit. You and the police burst into the house, catching the thief fish-handed. While that explanation was straightforward, solving puzzles like this often involves false starts and dead ends. Part of the trick is to use the process of elimination and lots of trial and error to hone in on the right pieces, and the more logic puzzles you solve, the better your intuition will be for when and where there's enough information to make your deductions. And did young Einstein really write this puzzle? Probably not. There's no evidence he did, and some of the brands mentioned are too recent. But the logic here is not so different from what you'd use to solve equations with multiple variables, even those describing the nature of the universe.

Frequently Occurring Word Combinations


ngrams of length 2

collocation frequency
blue walls 2
owner drinks 2



Important Words


  1. albert
  2. animal
  3. answer
  4. applied
  5. aquarium
  6. arrive
  7. assigned
  8. beer
  9. beverage
  10. bird
  11. blends
  12. blue
  13. bluemaster
  14. brain
  15. brand
  16. brands
  17. brit
  18. burst
  19. case
  20. cat
  21. catching
  22. center
  23. cigar
  24. city
  25. clear
  26. clue
  27. clues
  28. coffee
  29. color
  30. column
  31. complex
  32. conclude
  33. culprit
  34. dane
  35. dead
  36. deductions
  37. describing
  38. detective
  39. devising
  40. dog
  41. door
  42. drink
  43. drinker
  44. drinks
  45. dunhill
  46. einstein
  47. eleven
  48. elimination
  49. ends
  50. equations
  51. error
  52. evidence
  53. examine
  54. expert
  55. explanation
  56. false
  57. fifteen
  58. figure
  59. fill
  60. find
  61. fish
  62. fourteen
  63. fourth
  64. gather
  65. genius
  66. german
  67. give
  68. grid
  69. helpful
  70. history
  71. home
  72. hone
  73. horse
  74. hours
  75. house
  76. houses
  77. identical
  78. immediately
  79. information
  80. interior
  81. intuition
  82. involves
  83. involving
  84. leaves
  85. left
  86. list
  87. live
  88. lives
  89. logic
  90. logical
  91. lot
  92. lots
  93. mall
  94. meaning
  95. mentioned
  96. milk
  97. missing
  98. multiple
  99. nationality
  100. nature
  101. neighbor
  102. norwegian
  103. organize
  104. owner
  105. painted
  106. pall
  107. part
  108. path
  109. pause
  110. people
  111. person
  112. physics
  113. pick
  114. pieces
  115. place
  116. police
  117. process
  118. putting
  119. puzzle
  120. puzzles
  121. rarest
  122. realize
  123. resist
  124. riddle
  125. root
  126. scene
  127. scent
  128. screen
  129. search
  130. shot
  131. showed
  132. sleuthing
  133. smartest
  134. smoker
  135. smokes
  136. solution
  137. solve
  138. solving
  139. spot
  140. start
  141. starts
  142. step
  143. stolen
  144. straightforward
  145. street
  146. sudoku
  147. supposedly
  148. swede
  149. tackling
  150. tea
  151. teaser
  152. tells
  153. ten
  154. thief
  155. thirteen
  156. trail
  157. trial
  158. trick
  159. turned
  160. twelve
  161. type
  162. unassigned
  163. universe
  164. upside
  165. values
  166. variables
  167. video
  168. wall
  169. walls
  170. water
  171. write
  172. written
  173. wrong
  174. yellow
  175. young