full transcript

From the Ted Talk by Peter Paccone: How do US Supreme Court justices get appointed?


Unscramble the Blue Letters


There's a job out there with a great deal of power, pay, prestige, and near-perfect job security. And there's only one way to be hired: get aieppnotd to the US Supreme cruot. If you want to become a justice on the Supreme Court, the highest federal court in the utiend sattes, three things have to happen. You have to be nominated by the president of the United States, your nnmiaioton needs to be approved by the Senate, and finally, the president must frmlolay appoint you to the court. Because the Constitution doesn't specify any qualifications, in other words, that there's no age, education, profession, or even native-born citizenship requirement, a president can nominate any individual to serve. So far, six justices have been foreign-born, at least one never graduated from high school, and another was only 32 years old when he joined the bench. Most presidents nominate individuals who broadly share their ideological view, so a president with a liberal ideology will tend to appoint lbraiels to the court. Of course, a justice's leanings are not always so predictable. For example, when President Eisenhower, a Republican, nominated Earl Warren for Chief Justice, Eisenhower expected him to make ciaroetnvsve dceionsis. Instead, Warren's judgements have gone down as some of the most lreibal in the Court's history. Eisenhower later remarked on that appointment as "the biggest damned-fool mistake" he ever made. Many other fatrcos come up for consideration, as well, including experience, personal laityeols, ethnicity, and gender. The candidates are then thoroughly vetted down to their tax records and peytnams to domestic help. Once the president interviews the candidate and makes a formal nomination announcement, the stneae leadership traditionally tnrus the nomination over to hearings by the Senate jauircidy ctemtimoe. dipendeng on the contentiousness of the choice, that can stretch over many days. Since the Nixon administration, these hearings have agaerevd 60 days. The nominee is interviewed about their law record, if applicable, and where they stand on key isseus to discern how they might vote. And especially in more recent history, the committee tries to unearth any dark secrets or past indiscretions. The Judiciary Committee votes to send the nomination to the full Senate with a positive or negative recommendation, often rlfevciete of political leanings, or no recommendation at all. Most rejections have happened when the Senate mjrtoiay has been a different political party than the president. When the Senate does aopvrpe, it's by a simple majority vote, with ties broken by the vice president. With the Senate's consent, the president issues a wrtetin appointment, allowing the nominee to complete the final steps to take the cttoonainuistl and judicial oaths. In doing so, they solemnly swear to administer justice without respect to persons and do equal right to the poor and the rich and faithfully and impartially discharge and perform all the dtieus incumbent upon a US Supreme Court jutscie. This job is for life, barring resignation, retirement, or removal from the court by impeachment. And of the 112 justices who have held the position, not one has yet been removed from office as a result of an icemhaempnt. One of their roles is to protect the fundamental rights of all arcaeimns, even as different parties take power. With the tmoeudners impact of this riseinliobstpy, it's no wonder that a US Supreme Court justice is eetcxepd to be, in the words of Irving R. Kaufman, "a pargoan of virtue, an intellectual Titan, and an administrative wazrid." Of course, not every member of the Court turns out to be an exemplar of justice. Each lvaees behind a legacy of decisions and opinions to be debated and deseitscd by the ultimtae judges, time and history.

Open Cloze


There's a job out there with a great deal of power, pay, prestige, and near-perfect job security. And there's only one way to be hired: get _________ to the US Supreme _____. If you want to become a justice on the Supreme Court, the highest federal court in the ______ ______, three things have to happen. You have to be nominated by the president of the United States, your __________ needs to be approved by the Senate, and finally, the president must ________ appoint you to the court. Because the Constitution doesn't specify any qualifications, in other words, that there's no age, education, profession, or even native-born citizenship requirement, a president can nominate any individual to serve. So far, six justices have been foreign-born, at least one never graduated from high school, and another was only 32 years old when he joined the bench. Most presidents nominate individuals who broadly share their ideological view, so a president with a liberal ideology will tend to appoint ________ to the court. Of course, a justice's leanings are not always so predictable. For example, when President Eisenhower, a Republican, nominated Earl Warren for Chief Justice, Eisenhower expected him to make ____________ _________. Instead, Warren's judgements have gone down as some of the most _______ in the Court's history. Eisenhower later remarked on that appointment as "the biggest damned-fool mistake" he ever made. Many other _______ come up for consideration, as well, including experience, personal _________, ethnicity, and gender. The candidates are then thoroughly vetted down to their tax records and ________ to domestic help. Once the president interviews the candidate and makes a formal nomination announcement, the ______ leadership traditionally _____ the nomination over to hearings by the Senate _________ _________. _________ on the contentiousness of the choice, that can stretch over many days. Since the Nixon administration, these hearings have ________ 60 days. The nominee is interviewed about their law record, if applicable, and where they stand on key ______ to discern how they might vote. And especially in more recent history, the committee tries to unearth any dark secrets or past indiscretions. The Judiciary Committee votes to send the nomination to the full Senate with a positive or negative recommendation, often __________ of political leanings, or no recommendation at all. Most rejections have happened when the Senate ________ has been a different political party than the president. When the Senate does _______, it's by a simple majority vote, with ties broken by the vice president. With the Senate's consent, the president issues a _______ appointment, allowing the nominee to complete the final steps to take the ______________ and judicial oaths. In doing so, they solemnly swear to administer justice without respect to persons and do equal right to the poor and the rich and faithfully and impartially discharge and perform all the ______ incumbent upon a US Supreme Court _______. This job is for life, barring resignation, retirement, or removal from the court by impeachment. And of the 112 justices who have held the position, not one has yet been removed from office as a result of an ___________. One of their roles is to protect the fundamental rights of all _________, even as different parties take power. With the __________ impact of this ______________, it's no wonder that a US Supreme Court justice is ________ to be, in the words of Irving R. Kaufman, "a _______ of virtue, an intellectual Titan, and an administrative ______." Of course, not every member of the Court turns out to be an exemplar of justice. Each ______ behind a legacy of decisions and opinions to be debated and _________ by the ________ judges, time and history.

Solution


  1. majority
  2. responsibility
  3. issues
  4. payments
  5. constitutional
  6. wizard
  7. conservative
  8. united
  9. states
  10. approve
  11. nomination
  12. averaged
  13. formally
  14. factors
  15. decisions
  16. dissected
  17. impeachment
  18. justice
  19. ultimate
  20. court
  21. liberals
  22. depending
  23. loyalties
  24. written
  25. duties
  26. senate
  27. tremendous
  28. judiciary
  29. leaves
  30. committee
  31. reflective
  32. paragon
  33. turns
  34. liberal
  35. expected
  36. americans
  37. appointed

Original Text


There's a job out there with a great deal of power, pay, prestige, and near-perfect job security. And there's only one way to be hired: get appointed to the US Supreme Court. If you want to become a justice on the Supreme Court, the highest federal court in the United States, three things have to happen. You have to be nominated by the president of the United States, your nomination needs to be approved by the Senate, and finally, the president must formally appoint you to the court. Because the Constitution doesn't specify any qualifications, in other words, that there's no age, education, profession, or even native-born citizenship requirement, a president can nominate any individual to serve. So far, six justices have been foreign-born, at least one never graduated from high school, and another was only 32 years old when he joined the bench. Most presidents nominate individuals who broadly share their ideological view, so a president with a liberal ideology will tend to appoint liberals to the court. Of course, a justice's leanings are not always so predictable. For example, when President Eisenhower, a Republican, nominated Earl Warren for Chief Justice, Eisenhower expected him to make conservative decisions. Instead, Warren's judgements have gone down as some of the most liberal in the Court's history. Eisenhower later remarked on that appointment as "the biggest damned-fool mistake" he ever made. Many other factors come up for consideration, as well, including experience, personal loyalties, ethnicity, and gender. The candidates are then thoroughly vetted down to their tax records and payments to domestic help. Once the president interviews the candidate and makes a formal nomination announcement, the Senate leadership traditionally turns the nomination over to hearings by the Senate Judiciary Committee. Depending on the contentiousness of the choice, that can stretch over many days. Since the Nixon administration, these hearings have averaged 60 days. The nominee is interviewed about their law record, if applicable, and where they stand on key issues to discern how they might vote. And especially in more recent history, the committee tries to unearth any dark secrets or past indiscretions. The Judiciary Committee votes to send the nomination to the full Senate with a positive or negative recommendation, often reflective of political leanings, or no recommendation at all. Most rejections have happened when the Senate majority has been a different political party than the president. When the Senate does approve, it's by a simple majority vote, with ties broken by the vice president. With the Senate's consent, the president issues a written appointment, allowing the nominee to complete the final steps to take the constitutional and judicial oaths. In doing so, they solemnly swear to administer justice without respect to persons and do equal right to the poor and the rich and faithfully and impartially discharge and perform all the duties incumbent upon a US Supreme Court justice. This job is for life, barring resignation, retirement, or removal from the court by impeachment. And of the 112 justices who have held the position, not one has yet been removed from office as a result of an impeachment. One of their roles is to protect the fundamental rights of all Americans, even as different parties take power. With the tremendous impact of this responsibility, it's no wonder that a US Supreme Court justice is expected to be, in the words of Irving R. Kaufman, "a paragon of virtue, an intellectual Titan, and an administrative wizard." Of course, not every member of the Court turns out to be an exemplar of justice. Each leaves behind a legacy of decisions and opinions to be debated and dissected by the ultimate judges, time and history.

Frequently Occurring Word Combinations


ngrams of length 2

collocation frequency
supreme court 3
judiciary committee 2
court justice 2

ngrams of length 3

collocation frequency
supreme court justice 2


Important Words


  1. administer
  2. administration
  3. administrative
  4. age
  5. allowing
  6. americans
  7. announcement
  8. applicable
  9. appoint
  10. appointed
  11. appointment
  12. approve
  13. approved
  14. averaged
  15. barring
  16. bench
  17. biggest
  18. broadly
  19. broken
  20. candidate
  21. candidates
  22. chief
  23. choice
  24. citizenship
  25. committee
  26. complete
  27. consent
  28. conservative
  29. consideration
  30. constitution
  31. constitutional
  32. contentiousness
  33. court
  34. dark
  35. days
  36. deal
  37. debated
  38. decisions
  39. depending
  40. discern
  41. discharge
  42. dissected
  43. domestic
  44. duties
  45. earl
  46. education
  47. eisenhower
  48. equal
  49. ethnicity
  50. exemplar
  51. expected
  52. experience
  53. factors
  54. faithfully
  55. federal
  56. final
  57. finally
  58. formal
  59. formally
  60. full
  61. fundamental
  62. gender
  63. graduated
  64. great
  65. happen
  66. happened
  67. hearings
  68. held
  69. high
  70. highest
  71. history
  72. ideological
  73. ideology
  74. impact
  75. impartially
  76. impeachment
  77. including
  78. incumbent
  79. indiscretions
  80. individual
  81. individuals
  82. intellectual
  83. interviewed
  84. interviews
  85. irving
  86. issues
  87. job
  88. joined
  89. judgements
  90. judges
  91. judicial
  92. judiciary
  93. justice
  94. justices
  95. kaufman
  96. key
  97. law
  98. leadership
  99. leanings
  100. leaves
  101. legacy
  102. liberal
  103. liberals
  104. life
  105. loyalties
  106. majority
  107. member
  108. negative
  109. nixon
  110. nominate
  111. nominated
  112. nomination
  113. nominee
  114. oaths
  115. office
  116. opinions
  117. paragon
  118. parties
  119. party
  120. pay
  121. payments
  122. perform
  123. personal
  124. persons
  125. political
  126. poor
  127. position
  128. positive
  129. power
  130. predictable
  131. president
  132. presidents
  133. prestige
  134. profession
  135. protect
  136. qualifications
  137. recommendation
  138. record
  139. records
  140. reflective
  141. rejections
  142. remarked
  143. removal
  144. removed
  145. republican
  146. requirement
  147. resignation
  148. respect
  149. responsibility
  150. result
  151. retirement
  152. rich
  153. rights
  154. roles
  155. school
  156. secrets
  157. security
  158. senate
  159. send
  160. serve
  161. share
  162. simple
  163. solemnly
  164. stand
  165. states
  166. steps
  167. stretch
  168. supreme
  169. swear
  170. tax
  171. tend
  172. ties
  173. time
  174. titan
  175. traditionally
  176. tremendous
  177. turns
  178. ultimate
  179. unearth
  180. united
  181. vetted
  182. vice
  183. view
  184. virtue
  185. vote
  186. votes
  187. warren
  188. wizard
  189. words
  190. written
  191. years